Do you GriGri?

More
18 years 6 months ago - 18 years 6 months ago #127468 by oldtimer
Replied by oldtimer on topic My Yo-Yo (RADS ) set up
I use the Basic Ascender from PETZL in the top, the tail line goes down into the Grigri that is tied to the center ring in the harness, that exiting tail goes up to a micro pulley that hangs from the bottom hole in the Basic Ascender and them down again all the way to the ground. I assume someone has taken a closed up picture of this set up because we had this discussion about last year and it quickly caught on fire about the proper name of the system and why we should call it a RADS instead to keep nomenclature clear and consistent with he other parts of the Arborist world. Or something to that effect! Joe of the Jungle showed me this System for the first time at the Rendezvous in Nebraska in 2004

Here are the pictures of Tom Dunlaps set up and further disscusion at the TCIBoard site link:
http://www.tci-forums.com/viewthread.php?tid=524

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

More
18 years 6 months ago - 18 years 6 months ago #127469 by sitka12
Replied by sitka12 on topic Do you GriGri?
Not only am I going off topic, but I'm straying to beat a ghost horse. I was reading through that link you posted and there was a lot of discussion about the potential for a toothed handled ascender to tear up a rope if shock loaded during SRT. However, in a RADS system that uses either a Gri Gri or ID, wouldn't that device recieve the shock load rather than the handled ascender? Pretend that during a RADS ascent that a small branch broke sending the climber down a few feet. During any phase of the RADS climb the ID or Gri Gri should be the first and only device to be loaded. The handled ascender only serves as a backup and therefore could not destroy the rope. Any comments regarding this issue?

Also, and back on topic, if using a Gri Gri for descending, should it be backed with a prussik or is that overkill?

Finally, reading many posts over at the rock-climbing forum about the Gri Gri and Trango Cinch, everyone says to never use them as a self belay. Is there something I'm missing here, or are we using it incorrectly?

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

More
18 years 6 months ago - 18 years 6 months ago #127480 by oldtimer
Replied by oldtimer on topic Do you Grigri?
Hello Sitka
Some facts have been agreed upon by the "mayor experts" in the 3 main WEB Boards. (1)Mechanical ascenders do not destroy arborists ropes on the typical falls that arborists may experience. They have done extensive tests dropping heavy objects in a lab and have not reached the complete failure of the typical arborist rope either by Grigris or mechanical toothed ascenders.
(2) On Backing up a Grigri. The instructions that I got from the manufacturer did not mentioned any need to back it up. I posted a "Self Rescue Scenario" that occurred to me a few weeks back. It was agree upon that there was not need to use a back up for the GriGri and it could only cause more problems than it would solve. I learned my lesson.
I have never used a Trango Cinch so I do not care to give any opinion. Here is a post from one of the dealers.

"The Cinch is the latest in a long line of innovative belay devices introduced by Trango. We designed it with an eye for function, aesthetics and simplicity (It’s about as complicated as a door hinge.) so it offers up a bombproof belay for ropes from 9.4mm to 11mm. On smaller diameter ropes, or when holding falls that generate extremely high loads (In excess of factor 1) the Cinch acts dynamically, reducing shock loads to the belay system. In addition it will release easily and modulate fluidly while you’re rappelling or lowering off. The Cinch feeds rope easier than any other device, fits nicely in your hand and weighs 170gm." It sales from about 55 to 69 bucks depending on dealer.

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

Time to create page: 0.057 seconds
Powered by Kunena Forum

Join Our Mailing List